Surprised by Jesus Vol 2

Author:
Simon Hill
Date:
December 10, 2025
Type:
Category:

A disturbed ruler (Matthew 2:1-23)

Matthew’s gospel tells us Jesus was born at the time of King Herod. When Herod was 34 he fled to Rome for protection, to his old friend Mark Anthony, who admired what he saw as Herod’s heroic qualities. Caesar Augustus was also a champion for Herod because he remembered the loyalty of Herod’s father towards his adopted father Julius Caesar. So, Caesar Augustus and Antony convened the Roman Senate who voted unanimously to make Herod “The king of the Jews” (a Roman title - not a Jewish one).

With the endorsement of Rome, Herod returns to Israel and fights his way to win the kingdom. He beheads the last male of the Hasmoneans (ruling dynasty), and also his wife and his daughter! To divide loyalties between the people, Herod takes one of the last heirs of the Hasmonean dynasty, as his wife. Matthew Ch 3:3, tells us that when the wise men came looking for Jesus, Herod is disturbed, and the whole of Jerusalem with him. The whole city, by extension, suffers from Herod’s paranoia, the fear that another has power over him.

Paranoia was not uncommon for Herod. The important ancient Jewish historian, Josephus, tells us that towards the end of Herod’s reign, daily life in the palace descended into a darkness of spying, blackmail, torture and murder. It was into this tyrannical kingdom, ruled by a dangerous and murderous madman, that Jesus Christ was born.

Herod’s response to baby Jesus was to murder all of the boys in Bethlehem under two years of age, as any could be the boy he was informed about. Even a baby was a threat to Herod’s power, so great, that bloodshed was justifiable. Herod models what we so often see in the world. The powerful, making life miserable for those below them. Herod exerts power for his own good, without a care for the impact on others.

The good surprise of Christmas is that it shows God’s pattern, in stark contrast to Herod’s, that God embraces weakness and gives up power. Lowering himself and entering the world as a weak, vulnerable and dependent baby. God uses power, never in a self-serving manner, but only for our good. The humbleness of Jesus’ birth is surpassed by his death through which he offers victory over death and the chance for all people to become friends with God.

Isn’t Jesus the type of king who would say to us, “hey, if you find a better offer that is true, you should take it!”—what does that say about the type of king Jesus is?


Simon Hill - Simon enjoys thinking and writing about theology, particularly seeing it become practical. His academic and professional experience has been in engineering, theology and ministry. 

Photo by Paweł Furman on Unsplash

Other Surprised by Jesus articles
1. Overturned religion, power and importance
3. The wise worship a baby
4. Government and militaristic power are turned upside-down

Recent Posts

August 18, 2026
7 Ways to Fight Distraction in Prayer

Prayer is a life giving connection with God and yet it can sometimes be difficult to stay engaged. Gavin Ortlund provides a few practices to help focus on being with God while we pray. Distraction can be a huge hindrance in our prayer life, but I’m also discovering it provides an opportunity for growth. Here […]

Read More
August 17, 2026
Learning to Lament: A Guide to Praying in Our Hardest Moments

When life is hard or sorrowful, a mountain of different thoughts and feelings can come as we approach prayer. Hear a first hand account of deep sorrow that lead to seeking God and how to Lament. "I was heartbroken—but that was okay, wasn’t it? Honestly, I was no longer sure. Perhaps my pain was meant […]

Read More
July 15, 2026
Against Ambition

Undeceptions John Dickson starts season 2 of his Undeceptions podcast beginning with the topic of Ambition with Miroslav Volf. Dickson givesthe warning: "making this episode almost changed my life."It's so helpful for Christians saturated in the Wests culture of performance and productivity. High performers – athletes, business professionals, artists, and the like – inspire and […]

Read More

Categories

linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram